Posted by: Bob Gorman | May 23, 2017

Extended Netting at Nine Major League Parks

So far, nine major league parks have extended their safety netting beyond the minimum suggested by the baseball commissioner’s office.  Clubs that put the safety of fans first are the Texas Rangers, Washington Nationals, Kansas City Royals, Minnesota Twins, St. Louis Cardinals, Philadelphia Phillies, Pittsburgh Pirates, Houston Astros, and Atlanta Braves.  None of these clubs have suffered any appreciable drop in ticket sales as a result of the extended netting.  As reported by Maury Brown at Forbes (https://www.forbes.com/sites/maurybrown/2017/05/15/as-injuries-gain-visibility-how-serious-is-major-league-baseball-about-fan-safety/#42ebb2993737), the Texas Rangers experienced only some minor complaints about its decision to extend the netting.  Stated one club official, “Obviously, there was some initial reaction and we worked with customers individually on those concerns.  But overall, we were about to satisfy pretty much everyone with few exceptions and it became a non-issue very quickly.”

Posted by: Bob Gorman | May 23, 2017

Cubs Fan Dies in Fall

On May 17, 2017, Rick Garrity, 42, died from head injuries he sustained in a fall at Wrigley Field as he was leaving the stadium about 11:00 p.m. the evening before.  According to police, Mr. Garrity was attempting to climb the 36-inch-high handrail along the ramp leading from the right field upper deck seating area when he fell backwards, striking his head on the concrete walkway below.  Witnesses reported that the victim was holding a red cup in one hand as he climbed the railing.  Police stated that Mr. Garrity was sober at the time of the incident.  The Cook County medical examiners office ruled his death an accident.

Rafael Espinal, Jr, a member of the New York City Council, has introduced legislation that would require the Yankees and Mets to extend their existing protective netting to the foul poles in Yankee Stadium and Citi Field.  This law would be a major breakthrough for fan safety if it passes the New York City Council and would set a template for other MLB and MiLB cities to follow.  Here is the statement Council Member Espinal, Jr., released to the press.  Mr. Espinal, Jr., represents the 37th Council District in Brooklyn and serves as Chair of the Committee on Consumer Affairs:

New Yorkers love baseball, and we especially love our Mets and Yankees. But our hometown teams should do more to reciprocate that love to their fans when it comes to public safety. We have all heard the horror stories of fans seriously injured at professional baseball games. Every year approximately 1,750 fans are injured by foul balls and broken bats. Not only are these injuries preventable, but the MLB, Yankees and Mets have been slow to implement a simple solution that would prevent families’ fun-filled ballpark outings from turning into nightmares.

This past year several fans lost their eyesight at ballgames. Think about that. They went to a baseball game and they left blind in one eye. All across America, fans, including children and the elderly, were hospitalized and had major surgery for brain and head trauma, concussions, bleeding on the brain, skull fractures, and eye damage, among many other permanent injuries.

In 2011 a New Yorker named Andy Zlotnick had major reconstructive eye and face surgery after getting hit by a foul ball in Yankee Stadium. Just days after Zlotnick was injured, a 12-year-old boy named Shlomo Shalomoff was hospitalized after getting slammed in the face by a foul ball at Citi Field. Both sat in right field seats — well past the first-base dugout.

MLB currently does not require protective netting for its ballparks. Instead, they leave fan safety decisions to the individual teams. MLB only “recommends” that teams install up to 70 feet of netting from behind home plate to the beginning of the dugouts. Consequently, just eight of the 30 major league teams have proactively added safety netting beyond MLB’s recommendation — the Yankees and Mets should be among them. While the players and coaches have protection in the dugouts, the fans sitting just a few feet behind them are left vulnerable.

Cost-effective and non-obstructive netting solutions already exist. The Texas Rangers’ retractable netting system can be raised and lowered to promote fan-player intimacy. Vertical netting would shield the scorching line drives from smashing into a fan’s skull, but allow pop-ups to be caught by fans sitting behind the nets. The new netting technology is ultra-thin, hi-tech fiber that is much less obtrusive than netting in the past.

Adding more protective netting will not impair the intimacy or fan experience. It will not reduce attendance or lead to lost season ticket holders. The Texas Rangers and Minnesota Twins added netting behind the dugouts last season and had no season-ticket cancellations. While some old time fans may no doubt grumble, baseball will be made better by becoming safer.

Many prominent players, coaches and managers have endorsed adding safety netting, including Yankees manager Joe Girardi, Twins manager Paul Molitor, Justin Verlander, Chipper Jones, and Cubs manager Joe Maddon, among others.

Perhaps most outspoken this past season was Phillies shortstop Freddy Galvis, who struck a young girl in the face with a line drive foul ball in August at Citizen’s Bank Park. Galvis felt terrible and urged MLB to extend netting.

“It’s 2016 and fans keep getting hit by foul balls when you’re supposed to have a net to protect the fans. Why don’t you put up a net and protect all the fans? It’s something you have to put before everything. Safety first. Safety.”

We New Yorkers are loyal to our hometown teams. We support the Yankees and Mets through good seasons and bad, we march with them in victory and suffer with them in defeat. Our teams should reciprocate that loyalty by prioritizing fan safety at all of their NYC stadiums. Unfortunately, today’s ballparks in our city are not safe enough and we must ensure this obligation is met.

That is why I am introducing legislation in the City Council that will require the city’s major and minor league ballparks to install additional protective netting from home plate to the foul poles as a matter of public safety. This legislation will ensure that baseball fans get protection from the dangers they face at our professional ballparks. Businesses in NYC that fail safety inspections must make their establishment safe for the public right away. Baseball should be no different.

Posted by: Bob Gorman | May 6, 2017

Braves Settle Foul Ball Lawsuit

A lawsuit filed in 2012 by the parents of a 6-year-old girl who was severely injured by a foul ball at an Atlanta Braves game has been settled.  On August 30, 2010, the child and her father were seated behind the third base dugout when the youngster was struck in the head by a foul ball off the bat of Melky Cabrera.  The blow fractured the girl’s skull in 30 places and resulted in traumatic injury to her brain.  The family incurred over $66,000 in medical bills as a result of the injury.  Among other issues, the lawsuit against the Braves and MLB asserted that steroid use among players resulted in harder hit balls, thus increasing the speed at which foul balls fly into the stands.  The suit also contended that the Braves failed to have enough safety netting even though the team and MLB knew that seats behind the dugouts are prime targets for foul balls.

Early in the proceedings, the Braves attempted to get the case dismissed, citing the “Baseball Rule” (assumption of risk) as their rationale.  Georgia does not recognize that doctrine as a defense and the Georgia Court of Appeals refused to invoke it.

Terms of the settlement were not disclosed.  A Braves spokesperson did state that the team’s decision to extend safety netting to the far ends of the dugouts in their new ballpark, SunTrust Park, had nothing to do with this lawsuit.

According to an April 3, 2017, New York Times article, Rafael Espinal, a member of the New York City Council, is considering proposing legislation that would require the Yankees and Mets to extend their existing protective netting 90 feet from home plate (MLB currently recommends that netting extend 70 feet from home plate).   Such a move would protect fans seated behind the dugouts at both stadiums.  “I’m baffled by why this is such a big issue,” he is quoted as saying.  “You have the money to put up the netting.  You would avoid the headaches of having to deal with injured fans.  Your players would feel less guilty when they go up to bat.”  Should this legislation be introduced and passed, it would be a significant step toward improving fan safety.  It also might encourage governmental bodies in other MLB cities to take similar action to protect their citizens from needless injury.

Posted by: Bob Gorman | January 26, 2017

A Personal Tragedy

In the debate over whether or not to extend protective netting, those who oppose any additional nets love to cite figures in an attempt to show that the likelihood of being injured by a foul ball or bat is statistically small in comparison to the number attending MLB and MiLB games every season.  What is often lost in this argument is that real people are suffering real injuries, many of them life-altering.   It’s easy to ignore a problem that has no face, that is depersonalized by citing a bunch of numbers.  The bottom line is that no one should suffer an injury from a ball or bat, especially since the solution is so simple.

What follows is the story of one such tragedy.  It is a tale I hear all too often.  And it is one that never should have happened.

On August 6, 2016, my husband’s life changed forever…at a baseball game.  An event we never imagined could happen and took an instant to transpire had a life-altering effect on his wellbeing.

We were in attendance at a much anticipated Braves vs. Cardinals game at Busch Stadium.  The Braves/Cardinals series in St. Louis is an annual pilgrimage we make from Atlanta to watch the game with our friends- rival Cardinals fans.  We were seated in section 144, row E at the far right side, the 3rd and 4th seats in.  We were watching and paying close attention to the game when in the bottom of the 8th, Tommy Pham of the Cardinals hit a broken-bat foul ball into the stands in our section.  I felt something fly by my face and lift my hair and immediately knew what had happened.   My husband, Rick, was struck directly in his left eye by a foul ball traveling at great speed.  He reacted immediately by placing both hands over his eye.  Fans all around us began calling for help from the medics.  A gentleman who introduced himself as a surgeon was at our side immediately to assess Rick’s condition.  He urged my husband to remove his hands so he could see if there was any projectile imbedded in his eye.  As soon as Rick pulled his hands away and I saw the injury, I knew the gravity of the situation.  EMT’s responded within seconds it seems and as soon as they determined Rick had not lost consciousness and could walk out of the stadium, they quickly escorted us to a First Aid area located at section 147.  There they applied a temporary bandage and got Rick and I to an ambulance immediately.  We were taken to Barnes Jewish Hospital where the full extent of his injuries would be determined.

Between 9:00 p.m. on August 6th and 8:30 a.m. on August 7th, multiple examinations and a 4 ½ hour surgery took place.  Suffice it to say that the outcome was less than favorable.  Rick’s injuries included a ruptured globe, blow-out fracture of the orbital floor, broken zygomatic arch, broken temporal-mandibular joint, and lacerations.  In layman’s terms, his eyeball was flattened, bones in the eye socket were fractured, his cheekbone and jaw were broken, and he had deep cuts.  He would never see out of that eye again.

img_1038

In the days following the injury, he has been seen by more doctors than we can remember, including surgeons and specialists,  to determine if there was any chance of meaningful vision in the left eye or if it needs to be removed and replaced with a prosthetic eye.  Based on the current state of the eye, very low likelihood of any meaningful sight, and the risks involved with surgery, it was decided that Rick will not undergo any further surgeries.  He will remain sightless in the left eye.

He wears polycarbonate glasses now full time to protect his right eye.  The left eye socket is sunken and the bony abnormalities are apparent now that all the swelling has gone down.  He still has his eyeball and will keep it as long as it doesn’t shrink too much and as long as it doesn’t cause him pain.  He isn’t in pain now, thank goodness.  He has some discomfort and he wants to rub the eye constantly.  The eye itself is pretty clouded over, but when he has his glasses on it isn’t very noticeable.

He functions well but there are things that are bothersome…large crowds where he  can’t see people approaching from the left, hand-eye coordination for close up work.  He is a tinkerer and is working on refinishing a boat and this is challenging.

You know before Rick’s accident I never gave this much thought.  Now it’s so obvious.  But this is the reason there is no fan outcry for more netting.  The public doesn’t know about it.  I think if more fans saw the faces of those injured or the actual injuries they might actually think twice about where they sit at the ball park.

Posted by: Bob Gorman | January 23, 2017

Fan Poll on Safety Netting

An HBO Real Sports/Marist Poll of 1,297 adults released on April 16, 2016, found that a majority (54%) of those surveyed think that MLB should expand protective netting along field level seating.  The survey, conducted with the Marist College Center for Sports Communication, reported that “50% of those fans would rather sit behind netting when close to the field, although only 41% of male baseball fans would compared to 61% of women.”  The preference for protective netting rises significantly when children are a factor.  A whopping 77% would prefer to sit behind netting if they are attending a game with small children.  The complete poll results can be found at http://sportscomm.marist.edu/

Posted by: Bob Gorman | January 23, 2017

Class Action Lawsuit Dismissed

On November 16, 2016, U. S. District Court Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers dismissed the class action lawsuit over netting and fan safety, citing data supplied by MLB that the risk of injury to fans was less than 1 percent.  Rogers did agree that “while rare, the severity of injuries that baseball spectators sustain in the modern era as a result of foul balls is significantly more severe than in the past.”  For the complete ruling, see https://dockets.justia.com/docket/california/candce/4:2015cv03229/289365

Posted by: Bob Gorman | August 30, 2016

Further Update on Class Action Lawsuit

Although she gave no indication as to when she would rule, it appears likely that the federal judge overseeing the class action lawsuit against California’s major league baseball stadiums over extended safety netting will allow the case to advance, according to a report in the Courthouse News Service (http://www.courthousenews.com/2016/08/24/suit-over-baseball-stadium-safety-nets-picks-up-steam.htm).  “One of the things that has always concerned me about this case are the allegations that the pitchers themselves do not allow their children to sit in those sections. Then I see the exhibit from Dodger Stadium and it’s interesting to me how often children are listed as the victims of the injury. Isn’t it time for a jury to decide if something is there?, ” Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers stated.

Posted by: Bob Gorman | August 29, 2016

Fan Injuries in 2016

What follows is a list of some of the serious injuries from balls and bats suffered by fans at major and minor league games during the 2016 season.  It is by no means a comprehensive list:

A Kansas City Royals fan, sitting along the third base line just beyond the newly extended netting in Kaufman Stadium, was struck in the face by a foul ball on April 3.  The ball hit him above his upper lip, causing him to lose consciousness for several moments.

A woman was struck in the eye by a foul ball during an April 15 game at Tropicana Field between the Rays and White Sox.  The ball passed through the gap left for television cameras between the original netting and the newly extended netting.  The victim was removed by stretcher and taken to an area hospital for treatment.  Several days after the incident, the Rays added netting to cover the gap.

A woman was struck in the face while trying to catch a foul ball at an El Paso Chihuahuas game on April 20.  She was transported to a local hospital as a precaution.

A 6-year-old boy was severely injured when struck on the head by a foul ball during a Charlotte Knights game the weekend of May 14.  Although the Knights had extended the safety netting to the far ends of the dugouts this season, the family was seated in the first row on the third base side just beyond where the new netting ended. The child sustained a skull fracture and a concussion which required hospitalization in an intensive care unit for several days.  Said the attending physician, “If you get hit in the head with a baseball going a hundred miles an hour, you can sustain skull fractures; you can sustain internal bleeding in your head that can possibly be fatal.”

A male fan seated five rows back from the third base visitors’ dugout was struck in the face by a piece of broken bat during a game at Fenway Park on May 14.  He sustained a two-inch cut above his right eye, but was able to leave the game without assistance.

A 7-year-old boy was struck on the left side of his head by a line drive foul ball at a May 17 game at Petco Park in San Diego. The screaming liner bounced back 20 rows in one section only to ricochet forward 12 rows to where he was seated two sections over down the right field line.  Fortunately, the youngster did not sustain severe injuries from the blow.

Even major league ball players are not immune from the dangers of foul balls.  Miami Marlins second baseman Derek Dietrich was struck on the back of his head by a foul ball that ricocheted off the dugout wall during the ninth inning of a game in Atlanta on May 29.  The blow knocked Dietrich down for several minutes, but he remained conscious.  Dietrich remained overnight in Atlanta as a precaution where he was examined and cleared to resume play the following day.

A woman at a June 29 Fisher Cats game  in Manchester, NH, was taken to the hospital after she was struck in the head by a foul ball while seated along the first base line.

A woman had to be removed by stretcher after she was struck in the head by a foul ball during the first inning of a game at Cleveland’s Progressive Field on July 26. The fan, seated down the right field line, may have been blinded by the sun and did not see the ball heading her way.

A young woman seated near the third base dugout at Montgomery’s Riverwalk Stadium suffered a ruptured left eyeball when struck by a foul ball during a Montgomery Biscuits game on August 13.   The damaged eyeball was completely removed a couple of weeks later. Local baseball broadcaster Melanie Newman tweeted that “it’s easily the most horrifying thing I have witnessed live. It’s changed a lot of things for my mindset.”

A young girl seated near the third base dugout was struck in the face by a foul ball off the bat of Freddy Galvis during a Phillies game on August 20.  Although the Phillies had extended the netting ten feet to the near ends of the dugouts, the child was seated in an unprotected area.  Said Galvis after the game, “What year is this? 2016? It’s 2016 and fans keep getting hit by foul balls when you’re supposed to have a net to protect the fans.  The fans give you the money, so you should protect them, right? We’re worried about speeding up the game. Why don’t you put up a net and protect all the fans?  What if I broke all her teeth. What if I broke her nose. If I hit her in one eye and she loses that. What are they going to do? They’re going to forget in three days.  It’s going to be a big deal for two, three days. Everybody in TV, media, whatever. But after three days what’s going to happen? They’re going to forget. But that family won’t forget that. Do you think the little baby will forget that? It’s true life. It’s something you have to put before everything. Safety first. Safety.”

The following day (August 21), a mother at a Phillies game was struck in the mouth by a foul ball while trying to protect her daughter. The ball ricocheted off the top of the third base dugout, striking the woman who was seated in the top rows of the lower level seating.  Freddy Galvis, who witnessed the injury, was seen to throw his hands up in frustration.

On August 22, a woman at a Brewers game in Miller Park was struck on the left ear by a line drive foul off the bat of Colorado’s Nick Hundley.  The injured fan was removed by stretcher and taken to an area hospital.

A woman was struck in the face by a foul ball that ricocheted off the roof of the visiting team dugout during the fourth inning of a Cleveland Indians game on September 4.  The injured fan, holding a bloody towel to her nose, needed assistance to walk to the first aid station.

A woman was seriously injured when a foul ball struck her in the face during the seventh inning of World Series Game 7 in Cleveland on November 2.  Knocked unconscious by the blow, she was taken from the stadium on a stretcher with her head and neck immobilized.

Older Posts »

Categories